Edgar the unborn theory

The Edgar the unborn Theory: A Fan Theory in the Brawl Stars Community

Background:
Umbert the Unborn, a comic strip by Gary Cangemi, ran from 2001 until the creator's untimely passing in 2017. The comic explored complex themes surrounding the pro-life vs. pro-choice debate, touching on sensitive topics like abortion, family trauma, and the challenges of living with personal convictions. The comic’s protagonist, Umbert, was an unborn child who was trapped in a sort of limbo, experiencing the emotions and struggles of a controversial pregnancy.

In 2017, Brawl Stars, a mobile game by Supercell, became a massive hit. Initially launched in select regions, it gained global popularity in 2018. The game is known for its colorful cast of characters, called “brawlers,” each with unique backstories and personalities. Among them is Edgar, a mysterious and angsty character who looks strikingly similar to Umbert from Umbert the Unborn. This uncanny resemblance has led to one of the most popular fan theories in the Brawl Stars community: Edgar is Umbert, grown up.

The Core of the Theory:

1. The Resemblance Between Edgar and Umbert:
   At the heart of this theory is the striking visual similarity between Edgar and Umbert. Both characters share a similar head shape and hair color, leading to speculation that Edgar might be a grown version of Umbert, who escaped the metaphorical womb and made it into the world of Brawl Stars.
   
   
   

2. Edgar's Tragic Backstory: According to the theory, Edgar’s traumatic past stems from his birth. Edgar’s mother, who was also Umbert’s mother, was pregnant with him while facing intense ridicule for her pro-life stance. She faced backlash from others who were pro-choice, creating a turbulent environment for her during pregnancy. Edgar’s father tragically passed away when Edgar was still a baby, leaving him to grow up emotionally scarred. The theory suggests that Edgar’s “emo” personality and attitude are a direct result of the trauma associated with his birth.
   
   
   

3. Byron’s Connection to Abortion: Another aspect of the theory ties the character Byron to the abortion debate. Byron was once an abortionist but decided to quit after a traumatic experience involving Vita, a character who had just been aborted. Byron’s decision to leave his profession was driven by his emotional reaction to the situation, and he later became involved in helping Edgar’s mother. This connection creates a deep and complex link between the characters.
   
   
   

4. The Story of Rosa and Vita: Rosa, the mother of Vita, who underwent an abortion, deeply regretted her decision and lived in isolation in the biodome, becoming an assistant to Bea. Eventually, Rosa becomes a “boxing bonist,” which further ties into the idea that these characters are all part of a larger, interconnected web that spans both Umbert the Unborn and Brawl Stars. Rosa’s emotional journey represents the complexities of the pro-choice/pro-life debate, adding more weight to the theory.
   
   
   

5. Elwood and Meg’s Role in the Narrative: Elwood, a character from Umbert the Unborn, eventually turns out to be Meg. Initially thought to be a boy, Meg’s true identity as a girl creates another layer of depth to the story. Meg’s parents were physics professors at MIT, which adds an intellectual background to her character. Her story parallels the journey of others who’ve had to navigate personal identity struggles.
   
   
   

6. Bull and Toby’s Tragic Story: The theory also explains Bull’s anger issues, suggesting that he may have had a stillborn twin brother named Toby. This loss has left Bull with unresolved grief and anger, which explains his violent and often volatile nature in Brawl Stars. This tragic backstory adds an emotional layer to Bull's otherwise straightforward character.
   
   
   

The Setting: Starr Park in Scranton, Pennsylvania

According to the theory, Starr Park, the fictional location in Brawl Stars, is actually based in Scranton, Pennsylvania. This is a significant link between Umbert the Unborn and Brawl Stars, as the events of Umbert the Unborn are said to have taken place in Scranton as well. The idea that both worlds are set in the same geographical location brings the theory full circle, merging the two universes in a way that feels both eerie and compelling.

The Timeline: A 15-Year Gap

The theory suggests that while Umbert the Unborn took place in 2001, the events of Brawl Stars unfold 15 years later, in 2016. This time gap allows for the characters to have aged and evolved in a world where trauma, political debates, and personal struggles have shaped them into the brawlers we know today.

Final Thoughts:
While this theory is speculative and involves sensitive topics, it has become a popular topic for discussion among Brawl Stars fans. The connections between Umbert the Unborn and Brawl Stars create an intricate, thought-provoking narrative that enriches the characters in unexpected ways. Whether or not it’s “canon,” the theory has undoubtedly sparked meaningful conversations about the complexity of human emotions and the weight of personal beliefs.